GIS Monitor Feb 1, 2001
-Autodesk Buys Gentry
-More on Autodesk GIS Design Server
-That’s My Story and I’m Sticking to It: More on V8Ball
-Points of Interest
-Week in Review
This issue sponsored by:
AUTODESK BUYS GENTRY
Coming fast on the heels of their move into location-based services,
Autodesk announced the completed purchase of Gentry Systems. Gentry, based
in St. Louis, has been building on the Autodesk platform for most of its
13 years in business. The company produced the top selling AutoCAD based
AM/FM/GIS system in the electric utility industry from 1992-97 according
to Clauder Systems Research. With a staff of 50, Gentry supports 300
electric utilities located in 45 states and 10 foreign countries. Their
customers tend to be smaller operations, such as towns and electric
cooperatives, in contrast to massive implementations from Smallworld and
In recent years Gentry has hedged its bets, and worked with both Autodesk
and ESRI. The product line includes products built on AutoCAD Map
specifically geared to the design and management of utilites, links to
trouble call applications, EDA (Embedded Distribution Analysis), as well
as a map viewer. Utility Design System, UDS is geared toward commercial
and residential electrical design. In March of 2000 Gentry entered into a
relationship with ESRI to port its applications to ArcInfo 8. Nothing
materialized from that relationship. In retrospect, it seems unlikely the
small company would have had the development resources and funds for such
a large project.
So, why should Autodesk purchase Gentry? This may be part of the ongoing
consolidation in the market. All of the major third party application
developers are slowly merging into larger concerns. Autodesk bought
Softdesk and Bentley bought all of its Strategic Affiliates. Also, the
acquisition of Gentry provides Autodesk’s GIS Division a solution to bring
its new GIS Design Server into the electric utilities marketplace.
====== a message from our sponsor ===============
ERDAS Has Your Solution
As the world's leading provider of geographic imaging solutions, ERDAS'
products are helping organizations like yours visualize, manipulate,
analyze, measure, and integrate any type of geographic imagery and
geospatial information into 2D and 3D environments.
MORE ON AUTODESK GIS DESIGN SERVER
I received follow up from Autodesk on some questions I had regarding their
new GIS Design Server.
Extensions: The cartridges they mention in the literature (long
transactions, routing) are not add-ons, but are included in the base
Pricing: Pricing is based per named user connection to the server. The
client is a free add-on to AutoCAD Map (which is not free.) Autodesk would
not give pricing at this time but suggests that it will be competitive
with ESRI and others.
Customer size: The product is aimed at organizations with 10 or more
Data loading: Users load data through AutoCAD Map by specifying (mapping)
DWG entities to database objects. Autodesk suggests that third party
loaders, including one from Safe Software, will be available.
Projections: The server handles projections before delivery to the client.
OpenGIS Specification Conformance: Autodesk plans to seek conformance.
Other databases: Autodesk has no immediate plans to support databases
other than Oracle.
Clients: For now, only AutoCAD Map, Autodesk MapGuide, and Autodesk OnSite
are clients to the Autodesk GIS Design Server.
NEW LAB OR A VACATION DESTINATION?
The U.S. Space & Rocket Center’s Geospatial Technology Application Center
(GTAC) is beginning a new teaching lab concept, Destination Lab. The US
Space & Rocket Center claims to be the world leader in immersive
simulation and interactive training. They are the people behind Space Camp
and Aviation Challenge, where kids and adults play astronaut and
experience simulated fighter pilot training. The Destination Lab is a
collaboration between the Center and SRI International, the folks behind
the .geo proposal, and Digital Earth. SRI also brings educational
resources from its Center for Technology in Learning.
The lab offers 3-5 day project-based classes that include technology
instruction, real-world application exercises, fieldwork and video
teleconferencing with GIS hotshots. The classes, called retreats, will
“revitalize” and “empower” attendees.
The “lab” locations vary. Ideally they are chosen to provide a “unique and
relevant field study setting” that is “"wired" for high tech
applications.” Destination Lab is “not a conference, a convention or a
workshop” but “a field-based, hands-on, minds-on, immersive lab retreat.”
For $3,000 you get 4 nights in a Florida hotel, meals, classes, and a ½
day admission to a Florida theme park. The first sessions are in
Celebration Florida (the town that Disney built); later ones are in Lake
Buena Vista and St. Augustine.
The first session in late February is titled: “Integrating Geospatial
Technologies into 21st Century Management.” The two key instructors are
URISA President, Lyna Wiggins, Ph.D., Department of Urban Planning and
Policy Development, Rutgers and Scott Madry, Ph.D., a professor of
Anthropology at UNC and founder and President of Informatics
International, Inc., who used to be at Rutgers. The second session, in
March covers “Geospatial Enabled Water Resource Management.” The faculty
is TBA. A third session will address “Preserving the Past-Growth
Management and Historic Preservation.”
Who’s supposed to attend? The first session targets: Planners, City
Officials, Department Heads, City Managers, City/County Engineers. The
second speaks to: EPA, State Officials, Conservation Office Employees,
Water District Officials, City and County Management, URISA members, GITA
members. As for experience, the labs are designed for novice through
I confess to being a bit skeptical. I’m all for hands on learning, group
work, and field experience. But this doesn’t sound all that new. It looks
like some lectures, some fieldwork and some group projects – a mix already
available elsewhere from vendors, universities and professional
organizations. I’m not sure that the companies and organizations/agencies
who employ the individuals noted above will fund this as training. I’ll be
very curious to see what the first graduates have to say.
THAT’S MY STORY AND I’M STICKING TO IT: MORE ON V8BALL
Some follow-up on my story last week questioning the legitimacy of an
“underground” MicroStation site (V8Ball) did generate a response from the
keeper of the site:
Hello Ms. Shutzberg (sic),
I must admit I'm a bit surprised at the attention you are giving me. In my
mind, the most important thing is that I'm providing info on the next
release of MS that no one else is. I'm getting a lot of positive response
from visitors to my site and it is spurring me to continue on.
Also, the editor of MicroStation Manager, Randall Newton wrote:
My only involvement in V8 Ball Web site was when I agreed to run the
anonymous "Cue" letter in MSM. I'm afraid you'll have to look elsewhere
for more information.
No matter what the truth, Bentley still risks being the loser. If they did
intentionally try to mislead their users, there’s bound to be a backlash.
If they are in fact uninvolved, the fact that someone is scurrying around
headquarters with a video camera and speaking publicly about unreleased
software (probably while prohibited by a a non-disclosure agreement)...well, that doesn’t look too good either.
Last week I reported that GIS Café no longer requires registration to
download their freebies. I was incorrect; you are still required to
complete a one-time registration (with cookies enabled). Most of their
freebies are freely available elsewhere without any registration.
POINTS OF INTEREST
-Continuing the retreat of “freebies” on the ‘Net, both PhoneFree and
DeltaThree have begun to charge for previously free PC-to-phone calls.
Net2Phone, the first player into that market is still free, but suggests
it may soon charge. PhoneFree says they must charge since advertising has
dried up. DeltaThree says its new goal is to target businesses instead of
-Update on MapReport. According to the folks at MapReport, the site that
puts news on the map, they’ve done some tweaking to make the maps less
cluttered and the locations more precise. The recent capture of the Texas
fugitives happened where? In Colorado. The icon is in Texas. Keep at it!
-About.com, a guide hosted directory, will offer free Web hosting for
small business and personal sites. The best part, your site is categorized
and searchable within About.com. About.com is the 6th largest Web
property. It has fine geography and GIS areas.
- Autodesk, with no fanfare, announced two new MapGuide Data Extensions:
one for ESRI SHP and one for Autodesk DWG. These allow the MapGuide server
to publish these formats without first converting them to MapGuide’s
native format. The kicker: you must PAY for these. I suppose I can
understand having to pay to support a “competing” format such as shape
files. Still, that format is public and many vendors support it for free
simply because it draws more users. I cannot, however, imagine asking
loyal users to PAY to use Autodesk’s own native DWG format directly. That
makes it seem as though the GIS Division is in competition with the rest
of company. The extensions will be available later this year; no
information on pricing.
GIS MONITOR BACK ISSUES
ADVERTISE WITH US
You can reach more than 6,000 GIS professionals every issue by sponsoring GIS Monitor. For more information, email us.
Please send comments and suggestions to:
GIS Monitor Editor
Ultimate Map/GIS Directory - Your search is over!
If you wish to subscribe, unsubscribe or change your preferences visit our