GIS MONITOR, November 1, 2001
- Who Writes GIS Articles, Anyway? Part II
- An Interview with RPM: Taking On Atlas GIS
- Windows XP and MicroStation V8 Ship: Does the Earth Move?
- Daratech Estimates GIS Software Revenue at $939 Million in 2000
Departments: Points of Interest, Letters, New Lists, Week in Review,
Issues, Advertise, Contact, Subscribe/Unsubscribe
If a URL runs more than one line, you may have to cut and paste the
line of the URL into your browser.
This issue sponsored by:
WHO WRITES GIS ARTICLES, ANYWAY? PART II
Last week’s article brought a flood of mail (see letters below)
suggesting that we as readers do indeed need to be careful in reading
Since those who don’t work with publications may not know how GIS
get to print, I’d like to share my experiences. The first GIS article
credit to me appeared in GIS World in May 1995 when I worked at Bentley
Systems. I say “credited” since I didn’t write it. Bentley hired
else to write it, and later told me my name would be on it. I wasn’t
comfortable with that, but I did get to edit it and do some fact
I decided then and there I’d never do that again.
I wrote my first CAD article in 1996, when I worked at ESRI. I was
by then CADENCE editor Kathleen Maher to write a feature article on
to vector conversion. When I explained to her that I knew nothing about
it, she said I’d be perfect! I didn’t even know what the going pay
was then, so I believe I let her set the fee. I wrote a second article
CADENCE a year later for then editor and current TenLinks CEO, Roopinder
Tara, on AutoCAD and the Web.
In 1998 I got a call from ESRI’s marketing department asking that I
an article about CAD/GIS integration for GIS World. That was tough since
had to try to be objective even though I worked for ESRI. ESRI was in
paying me my regular salary to write the piece. I must have done an OK
because I was asked to write a similar article in 2000, when I worked
Cadcorp. And, again, this was considered part of my duties. Also in
I was asked by a small mapping tools company to pen an article about
software. The requestor paid for the article, which later appeared in
I have also done some ghost writing. There are some who feel that’s
really fair, since the “true” writer gets no credit. I’ve found
you are writing on behalf of someone you understand and actually feel
comfortable “speaking for,” it can be quite rewarding. On the other
writing for someone you don’t “get” is approximately impossible.
Those are some, but likely not all, of the ways that articles from
make it to print. Where and whether these types of articles are
is at the discretion of the editors. As readers, and writers, we are at
Adena Schutzberg’s Publication List
====== a message from our sponsor ===============
HASP - software protection your customers will love.
HASP makes your software available to your customers in more flexible
ways, allowing applications to be used, rented
or activated on a per-use basis on any USB-enabled computer.
to learn more, and
register for our HASP web seminar.
AN INTERVIEW WITH RPM: TAKING ON ATLAS GIS
Last week Retail Profit Management (RPM) announced that they’d
agreement with ESRI to take over sales and support of Atlas GIS 4.0 and
port its look and feel to the ArcView 8.1 platform. I interviewed senior
partners Steve Lackow and Elio Spinello of RPM about their plans.
Q: Why did RPM take on the sales and marketing of Atlas GIS?
A: RPM has always been involved in the sales and marketing of Atlas.
been using Atlas products since Atlas Graphics was released in the 1980s
and Steve Poizner, SMI’s founder, answered the phone himself in
support. And we’ve been VARs and developers for 10 years, spanning the
SMI and ESRI eras. It’s always been the easiest product to teach and
support, and that is important to our customers, primarily in business,
sciences and health care.
Now, we’re essentially trying to address several audiences. There
unmet needs for service, support and extension among the legacy Atlas
users who have had no compelling reason to “upgrade” or change.
another group of Atlas users who would like to take advantage of the
capabilities of the broader ArcView platform, but the low level nature
ArcView 3.x has resulted in missing functionality, making this feel like
downgrade for many Atlas users. Now, with ArcView 8.1 we can easily
address those issues – adding both the functionality and the
of Atlas. We also think this platform and an Atlas extension of it will
attractive to users of other mapping and GIS systems.
Q: Will Atlas users be interested in an ArcView 8.x extension? Or is
extension equally aimed at ArcView users? I recall only a small fraction
of Atlas users moving to ArcView when ESRI extended an offer soon after
A: Atlas users have stayed with Atlas, even though to this day and at
least through the end of the year, they can still upgrade to ArcView 3.2
or 8.1 at the same prices as ArcView users can. They simply have not had
compelling reason to upgrade. Now, in implementing the function and feel
of Atlas on the ArcView 8.1 platform, we think we are providing that
compelling reason, or at least making it possible for Atlas users to
consider the switch. They couldn’t do so before, because ArcView 3.2
couldn’t meet their needs. If they still want to stay with Atlas 4,
OK too. We’ll support them.
As for ArcView users, the Atlas extension will make it a lot easier
everyday business tasks, for example assigning data by location to a
customer database or aggregating point data to regions. We also think
it will be of value to users of other GIS systems, who can utilize the
Atlas functionality and be more productive with the interface. We
that many users of other systems are looking for ways to migrate to ESRI
technology anyway, since it looks like the best bet for the future.
Q: Do I understand correctly that Atlas 4.0 will be the last version
Atlas built on its "original" code base? If not, what, if
you say about the arrangements with ESRI? I'm curious only because in
another case of a GIS being taken on after its "prime" by a
third party -
I'm thinking of GDS - there were issues when those taking over could not
have access to the source code to truly upgrade the product. .
A: Yes, Atlas 4.0 is the end of the line for releases on that
may introduce maintenance releases and updates, particularly to the
geocoder and the ZIP centroid file, and the data bundles. But it just
doesn’t make any more sense to us than it did to ESRI to undertake a
duplicitous effort to make Atlas contemporary - for example, to add
or map server capabilities or to swap out the flat-file database for a
relational one - when we have the benefit of ArcGIS technology to
Q: I’m afraid I have to admit that I’m one of the people who felt
“business geographics,” a market that Atlas addressed, never really
exploded. How do you view that niche market of GIS?
A: From a desktop perspective, GIS is going to be increasingly
“wizardized” so that one need not be a database or graphics expert,
alone a GIS expert, to use the technology productively. That is where
is going with the Business Analyst, and where Atlas is going at version
8.1. The desktop GIS products – all of them, including Atlas – have
too difficult to learn and to use straight out of the box. We promoted
Atlas for a long time as the “GIS for business when your business is
business, not GIS.” But truth be known, even Atlas hasn’t been easy
and suffers from the same kind of GIS-centricity as the other desktop
products. That is why GIS on the Internet and embedded GIS have been
such strong trends over the past 3 or 4 years. Mapquest alone has
exposed more people to digital mapping possibilities and capabilities at
faster rate than we could ever have imagined just a few years ago. We
now trying to include GIS as part of basic IT infrastructure, so much so
that users are taking advantage of spatial function without even knowing
they are, because the technology is built-in to their core info systems.
good example of this is the ability to select customers who live within
minutes of a store or a hospital without ever looking at a map. Finally,
through products like Mapquest, consumers have become more knowledgeable
with respect to the basic application and concepts related to GIS.
Q: Any thoughts that other GIS products in their mature years may
resurface as ArcView 8.x extensions?
A: We have our hands full with 3.2 extensions and scripts that want
8.1! Actually, I am wondering about what is going to happen with
I’ve long felt a kinship with many of the MapInfo users because they
more with similar business and social science applications as we do, and
have a terrific mailing list that is managed by Bill Thoen who goes out
his way to be of service to the users. I think the folks at MapInfo also
think that “business geographics” is a mature if not saturated
that this extends towards their entire attitude towards the desktop.
seem to be focusing on Internet and embedded GIS opportunities. It would
not surprise me at all if someone disenchanted with MapInfo and Map
came along and wrote a MapInfo for ArcView in VBA. With ArcGIS,
everything is there to build your own product. Don’t like ArcView?
Fine, roll your own interface and application, here are the objects, the
methods. Want a three-tiered application and not a desktop one? Fine,
we’ll deliver it as application service over the Geography Network
ArcIMS - which, by the way, we may very well do with Atlas 8.1 at some
Q: Why do you think Atlas has survived as long as it has?
A: That’s an easy one. Atlas GIS for Windows, 3.x and 4, is the
program ever. It might not be easy as pie, but right out of the box it
do so much more than ArcView or MapInfo or anything else. Its primary
strength has been a highly intuitive interface in which functions to
support commonly performed tasks are centralized and easy to access.
with a little user self-help and some ESRI training, and a VARs push in
the right direction, there’s a lot of room to learn and grow into the
Q: If you had run Atlas development/marketing at SMI or ESRI, what
you have done differently to expand Atlas' market share?
A: With the benefit of hindsight, there is quite a bit we’d do
differently. But acting on what was known at the time, I’m not sure.
ESRI, the big mistake was not fully leveraging how entrenched Atlas is
among its users and how loyal they are. You also have to keep in mind
at ESRI, and at RPM for that matter, making money is not our primary
objective. We are private, closely held companies with Big Goals. As
Bernstein tells the reporter in Citizen Kane, making money is not hard
do if that is all that you want to do. But we have a much greater vision
for the technology, a vision that extends to enhancing mutual
understanding among people all around the world, and to providing an
information platform that will support better management and
of the world’s precious resources.
Retail Profit Management
Oct 25 - Atlas GIS Returns to Market as an ArcView 8.x Extension
WINDOWS XP and MICROSTATION V8 SHIP: DOES THE EARTH MOVE?
Last week was a big week for product shipments. Two
much-talked-about, and somewhat hyped products, Microsoft’s new
operating system to end all
operating systems, Windows XP, and Bentley’s latest and greatest CAD
package, MicroStation V8, became available to the general public. An IS
manager from Boston who runs a mixed AutoCAD and MicroStation shop noted
that he didn’t feel the earth move.
I suspect most of us didn’t. The media has been all over Windows XP
its potential enforcement of the Microsoft way and continued
of consumers, in addition to significant privacy incursions. Still, the
general sense is that the operating system will be hard to avoid in most
consumer-level PCs and laptops in the coming months. Those who are
considering upgrading are pointed to the system’s overall stability
its “smartness” about working with digital cameras and other
devices. Detractors point to the privacy issues associated with
Microsoft’s Passport. They also note the screams of alternative
users who were locked out of MSN.com and Hotmail. The resulting
controversy over Microsoft’s lack of interoperability forced Microsoft
open the site up to all.
As for Bentley’s V8, the hype has been contained. Since beta
held to strict non-disclosures, there was very little discussion, except
in cursory ways on comp.cad.microstation, in the past months. Bentley
the bulk of the “campaigning” within the current user community, and
was quite low key.
Still, V8 does introduce some key things that make the product more
acceptable to AutoCAD and other CAD product users: unlimited layers and
the ability to read DWG directly. Bentley has also bent over backwards
make its new product accessible to all. There are new month-to-month
subscriptions and an aggressive competitive upgrade aimed at AutoCAD 14
users, who can purchase V8 for $888 in North America. ACAD 14 users in
other countries receive the product at half the local price. Both offers
run from today until December 31, 2001. I applaud Bentley’s choice of
focusing on core MicroStation for the rollout, leaving the engineering
configurations for later discussion.
Will the new release be a hit? The snippets I read from existing
MicroStation users, and beta testers, who are now free to speak, are
positive. The real trick is getting AutoCAD and other users to give V8 a
chance. My sense is that after all the past efforts to pull AutoCAD
away from their beloved platform – from free and low cost trade-ins,
aggressive marketing from competitors both in the vanilla CAD and
arenas – it’s not likely to happen. In addition to the “stickiness”
AutoCAD, I think Bentley made the “if you can’t beat them join them”
decision about real-time support of DWG too late.
Windows XP Finds A Home (Forbes.com)
Microsoft Belatedly Opens Access to MSN (CNET)
Bentley Releases MicroStation V8
Bentley Announces $888 Competitive Upgrade For AutoCAD
DARATECH ESTIMATES GIS SOFTWARE REVENUE AT $939 Million in 2000
Daratech, a company who develops market share numbers for GIS
has released its latest report: GIS Markets & Opportunities 2001,
available for $4950.
According to the report, state and local governments account for 20%
software sales. The software sales in turn support $7 billion in other
software, hardware, and services revenue.
The press release details market share this way:
GE Smallworld 6.9%
Sicad Geomatics 6.3%
Surprises? Not really. GE Smallworld revenues seem to be OK at $64.8
million, though the company seems rather quiet in the US. Sicad
does well in its native Germany, but it’s rarely seen in the US.
Autodesk’s GIS group products include civil engineering and mobile
applications, it’s arguable whether they are truly GIS. ERDAS and
each have about 2% of the market, along with a few other small
Likely lumped into the “other” category, covering 11%, are Bentley,
Manifold and other small players.
Oct 25 - Daratech: GIS Software Revenue Tops $939 Million in
POINTS OF INTEREST
- I’ve been following geo-targeting, where service providers sell
ability to locate your computer to those trying to target Web ads
geographically. The technology is in use! I was reading Wired and saw an
eBay ad with a misshapen map of Massachusetts (where I live) touting
eBay's local trading. I was taken to eBay, where a search tool had
plugged in that I wanted to look at things for sale near Boston. I could
also get searches near other big cities. It’s a start.
- GeoWorld reports that URISA’s annual conference attendance was
700, about half of what was expected. The conference ran from Oct. 21 to
24 in Long Beach, Calif.
- Intergraph Mapping and GIS Solutions has decided to extend the
for the GeoSpatial World 2002 call for presentations from October 31,
to November 20, 2001.
- At press time, NIMA was in talks with Space Imaging to continue its
exclusive contract for imagery of the Afghanistan war zone. NIMA paid
$1.91 million for the first 30 days of the contract, which runs out
- I hope to meet with many Illinois readers at the Illinois GIS
Association Fall Conference in Lisle next week.
- Caitlin Dempsey, former About.com GIS guide, details her
“Thanks for the news update in your TenLinks newsletter regarding
demise of http://gis.about.com.
That URL is now redirecting to Matt's
geography site but the content from the GIS site is being migrated to a
new home at http://gislounge.com.
The projected launch date is November
- The response to “Who Writes GIS Articles, Anyway?” was
gives me hope.
>From Dr. Duane F. Marble, professor emeritus of geography, Center
Mapping, The Ohio State University:
“Your comments in "Who Writes GIS Articles?" were well
taken. The shallow,
and often biased coverage of the trade journals in the GI S&T area
become worse over the last couple of years. I find little of any utility
in the ones that I receive and it seems to me to reflect the changing
pattern of ownership of the journals.
“Presently, there is no place to publish good, in-depth case
studies of GI
S&T applications. The little ESRI case study books help but they
>From Gary L. Schaffer, vice president, Product and Market
“Your article was on-target. Too many self-serving articles in this
industry. I appreciate your editorial approach.”
>From Felix Lopez Phillips, Applications Development Manager, Agra
“I could not agree more with your comments on the articles subject.
I've come across too many of those "product ad in disguised"
Internet lends itself for yet another pervasive practice: content
stealing. Now everybody writes an article as an expert on any subject,
sometimes I can't help but complain to the editor for gross errors and
inaccurate statements on technical articles I have come across
in the CAD and GIS area. Having worked in this area for over 15 years (I
started working at Intergraph in my native Venezuela when IGDS was
on DEC's PDP-11 systems) gives me an appreciation for publications from
writers like you and Ralph Grabowski, thanks for your professionalism.”
[Ralph Grabowski edits Upfront.ezine,
which is the inspiration and
older brother to GIS Monitor. – Ed.]
NEW LISTS AT TENLINKS.COM
Wine and GIS
WEEK IN REVIEW
Oct 31 - Intergraph Reports Operating Results for Third Quarter 2001
Once again, the company and its five divisions were profitable.
Oct 31 - Maine Hires Applied Geographics, Inc. Team
The firm will study and design a cost-effective statewide Geographic
Information System (GIS) with partners Camp Dresser and McKee and
Maine-based GIS Mapping and Analysis.
Oct 31 - Cingular Wireless Selects TCS as LBS Technology Provider
The carrier selected the TCS' Xypoint) Location Platform as one of the
vendors providing support for the company's Phase I and II wireless
Oct 31 - Verizon Wireless Negotiating E9-1-1 Contract With TCS
TCS entered into a Letter of Intent (LOI) with Verizon Wireless to
Phase I and Phase II wireless E9-1-1 location service.
Oct 31 - GEMI Corp Joins EarthScan's ImageNetwork*
EarthScan will develop an ImageCommerce* Solutions storefront for GEMI
Corp, which publishes Earth Observation Magazine (EOM) and Modern
Oct 31 - geoVue First to Issue 2000 Block Group Boundaries
geoVue released an updated version of the company’s flagship solution,
iSITE, with the new boundaries and data along with additional software
Oct 31 - Mobility Tracking Software Will Collect Traffic Data
The company developed probe collection software that enables it to
speed and location data from vehicles. Mobility will start with its own
traffic reporting fleet.
Oct 30 - HeyAnita Selects Kivera as LBS Provider
HeyAnita Inc., a voice software company, is utilizing Kivera Location
Engine technology in its location-based service offerings.
Oct 30 - Paragon/Galileo Group Sign Hyperspectral Imaging Deal
The alliance will fuse Galileo's proprietary spectral detection
(patents pending), with Paragon's image exploitation tools (ELT Series
Software) in a new product called SpotLite. SpotLite will enable users
ingest large spectral data cubes, apply algorithms and efficiently
identify selected target and features.
Oct 30 - LineSoft and Logica Announce Business Partnership
The business partnership has produced a joint interface product that
capitalizes on the successful integration efforts achieved at a number
Oct 30 - Now Users Can Add New Listings to Lasoo
Says the site: “Please note that only businesses and websites that
corresponding physical location on the Earth will be added to Lasoo.”
Oct 30 - USGS and FIU Join Forces to Fly
TerraFly will let visitors interactively fly over the Earth's surface
explore spatial data, such as aerial photography, satellite imagery,
street maps and locale information.
Oct 30 - ISTAR North American Image Catalog Tops 20,000 Square Miles
The additions of Dallas, Texas, and Buffalo, NY, put the company over
Oct 30 - WhereNet Adds Jaguar, Land Rover to Customer List
This service is about maintaining parts inventory wirelessly.
Oct 30 - Dakota Electric Selects GE Smallworld
GE Smallworld was selected in a competitive bid to assist Dakota
with developing a Technology Roadmap to support its IT strategies.
Oct 29 - GPU Telecoms Adopting Intergraph Geospatial OSS Solution
GPU Telecoms selected Intergraph's Geospatial Operations Support System
(G/OSS), OSP/Comms to support the development of the company's new fiber
optic communications network.
Oct 29 - French National Mapping Agency Chooses Laser-Scan
IGN has selected automated generalization technology from Laser-Scan.
Oct 29 - Mining Property Risk Info Online Through MDA's NLIS Hub
Property searches by solicitors in the UK involving the Coal Authority
now be processed electronically through the National Land Information
Service (NLIS) Hub.
Oct 29 - Link Digital Photos with GPS Information!
Your GPS tracks, you take digital pictures. When you get home the common
date/time stamp is used to automatically put lat/lon on the digital
and create Web pages with rough maps of the photo’s location.
Oct 26 - PlanGraphics Develop $ $1.3 Million GIS System for China
The company signed a multiyear contract with the government of China's
Sichuan Province to develop an urban management GIS for the Sichuan
Urban Environment Project Office, according to a news release. I don’t
where the release came from – it was not on the Plangraphics website.
was in the company's hometown paper.
Oct 26 - Chrysler to Offer Wireless Phone Link in Vehicles
Two very cool things are in this new offering: You can use your existing
cell phone and you pay just for the hardware, with no service charge.
Oct 26 - OpenOSX Releases Grass Pre 2 CD - Now Shipping
“Grass is the only real alternative to ArcView GIS, which
will cost more than US$20,000 and is not supported on the Macintosh)
platform.” So, I guess ArcView is NOT an option on the Mac, which is
platform the press release is touting.
Oct 26 - GEW Cologne AG Implements GE Smallworld
GEW Cologne AG, a large regional gas, electric, district heating and
utility in Germany, has begun implementing GE Smallworld geospatial
Oct 26 - OGC Puts out Requests for Multi-Hazard Mapping Initiative
Oct 26 - LocatioNet and Traxsis Establish LBS Partnership
LocatioNet customers will be able to locate wireless subscribers using
Traxsis GPS position solution; allowing location sensitive services
through the LocatioNet Platform.
Oct 25 - Manifold Achieves "Designed for Windows XP" Status
So far as I know, Manifold is the first to achieve this designation.
Oct 25 - Bentley Integrates MrSID in MicroStation V8
“MicroStation V8 users can now leverage MrSID to dramatically reduce
costs and time associated with capturing, storing, sharing and using
high-quality aerial imagery.”
Oct 25 - York County, SC Selects NovaLIS Solution
NovaLIS will provide York County, South Carolina with a complete
Assisted Mass Appraisal solution and Geographic Information System.
Oct 25 - Maporama Partners with Europcar
Maporama will provide online maps via Europcar websites.
Oct 25 - GeoConcept Triples Net Profits in Record 2001 Results
Founded 11 years ago, GeoConcept is now in its tenth profitable
GIS MONITOR BACK ISSUES
ADVERTISE WITH US
You can reach more than 6,000 GIS professionals every issue by sponsoring GIS Monitor. For more information, email us.
Please send comments and suggestions to:
GIS Monitor Editor
Ultimate Map/GIS Directory - Your search is over!
If you wish to subscribe, unsubscribe or change your preferences visit our